Topic started by SHYSUN (@ 184.108.40.206) on Tue Jul 10 03:59:07 EDT 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
Very disappointed to say,songs in majnu are boring,nothing new or innovative,mudar kanavae has been lifted from the not so forgotten "kannukkul nooru nilava idhu enna kanava" from vedam pudidu-hamsalekha.gulmohar was so hyped that it just fizzed out to be from pachai niramae which itself was a lift of tarzan boy.BONZAI is from chandiranai thottadu yaar -ratchagan ,which was lifted from sunita rao's pari hun main,well all of you will have to agree with these facts,my conclusion is all these guys,arr ,hj and co,do not compose in front of the directors,they just get inspired at nights as they say and give the tune to singers and wait for them to make modulations as all the singers have said in thier interviews,but there are composers who stick to their compositions and are very particular about it,harini has disclosed about this in jaya tv in an interview to abdul hameed,you know who iam mentioning about,all these guys are saleable no doubt,but 45 rupees of us is wasted.we are fools to buy inspired music ,it is sick and is worsening,is there so much of paucity in ideas to these guys who have a chance to prove,DISAPPOINTING !...
- From: sundar (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Tue Jul 10 04:34:44 EDT 2001
I corroborate the views.I pity the public who spend Rs 200-300 to buy CDs of these albums who are more foolish than the purchasers of audio cassettes.
What about ARR/HJ setting up Institute for Cut & Paste Technology in Film music"
It is not music direction but music editing.
- From: Kannan (@ caprx02.ext.nokia.com)
on: Tue Jul 10 09:16:48 EDT 2001
as for the comments about the three songs...... i second u'r views.... they are absolute copies with different lyrics...! pity !!!!
as with the "hari gori bonsayi" - can some one enlighten me of its meaning!!!! thamarai madam, r u the same one who was able to pen vaseegara??? pity u too!!!
as with HJ, i reserve my judgements for a while as he did get my attention with the MG srikumar number(pinju thendrale )!!!! but then again .......may be its a remake too since my knowledge pool is quite restricted when it comes to music!!!
- From: veriyan (@ klj-229-109.tm.net.my)
on: Tue Jul 10 14:00:26 EDT 2001
Vedam puthithu - MD is Devendiran not hamsaleka
- From: vc (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Sat Jul 14 02:28:08 EDT 2001
vedham pudhithu is by IR
- From: Common Friend (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Sat Jul 14 12:53:33 EDT 2001
Veriyan is right .
VP is by Devendiran.
- From: Fliflo (@ tnt2-165-244.cac.psu.edu)
on: Sat Jul 14 13:04:25 EDT 2001
Majnu songs are availabl at www.raaga.com
- From: shysun (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Tue Jul 17 05:13:32 EDT 2001
sorry it was by devendiran,but mudarkanavae is a copy of kannukkul noo nilava.
- From: poor ARR (@ inet-netcache1-o.oracle.com)
on: Tue Jul 17 21:55:11 EDT 2001
you have very nicely accused ARR of the same things as HJ . fine! can you point to some audio files about these so-called originals of ARR's songs so that we can feel better ?
So, in conclusion, any of ARR's songs is not his creativity but that he lifts some song, the singers put all their 'creativity' into it and make it sound good ( I hope u agree atleast with this). If u don't agree, then the songs are not good which means the singers dint do a good job. So, in accusing ARR of delivering 'bad' songs, you are also accusing a gamut of singers he has used. which includes SPB, Chitra, KJY etc ....
Now, if his songs are good as opposed to bad, then shall we give some credit to him that he had the sense to accept the 'made-good' song by the singer ? instead of rejecting that ? or was he using someone else's approval for this b4 punching his name on the song .. now, who can this someone else be ? SHYSUN and his cronies ?
please enlighten !!! ..
- From: shysun (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Wed Jul 18 09:46:10 EDT 2001
poor arr ,get real,spb is a creative genius so are chitra and kjy,please refer arrs songs with these 3 artistes you mentioned,they have neither been great hits if so it may be because of their additional creative inputs no doubt,also note,if arr is lifting a tune to alter he has not used these prominent singers,but newcomers,why are you so upset at reality,arr is not an impromptu composer he is an extemporaneous plagiariser working at night,he is so proud of it so are you,keep this in mind,harini in her latest interview to mr.abdul hameed says raaja is the only composer commanding straight singing of his compositions,she has also said deva arr and others give full freedom,listen to me carefully,IF BEETHOVEN AND BACH ETC have let their players play at wish ,all these western classics will not be here for us to cherish,if our saint composers did the same as arr we will not have these excellent raagas,my strong conclusion is arr is no composer he is a plagiariser,raaja is the only composer....now u reply...
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum