Topic started by suresh (@ 188.8.131.52) on Sun Aug 17 08:08:22 EDT 2003.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
I CANNOT ABLE TO UNDERSTAND WHY UDIT NARAYAN IS GETTING LOT CHANCES IN TAMIL FILMS. THERE ARE PLENTY OF TALENTED TAMIL GUYS ARE WAITING FOR TAMIL SONGS. BUT VIDHAYSAGAR IS GIVING MUCH IMPORTANCE TO UDIT NARAYANA.
- From: velu (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Mon Aug 18 01:56:36 EDT 2003
A.R.Rahman and Vidhyasagar are the real promoters of such useless singers.They are great music composers undoubtedly but why do they just use signers like udith narayan,sukvinder singh,sadhana sargam sonu nijam etc.
- From: curses (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Mon Aug 18 09:06:41 EDT 2003
Sonu Nigam's sung a song in parthen Rasithen.. (music Bharadwaj).. Has he sung nething else in tamil?
- From: Anbe sivam (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Fri Aug 22 13:51:30 EDT 2003
Now ARR has introduced new set of tamil killers in Boys album. Composition was peppy, but why to waste it with such singers.
Earlier, he use to give one song in a album like this to add flavour, which was bearable. Now in Boys he set a trend of giving most of the album to such singers. Hope other MDs don't follow that trend due to success of Boys.
- From: vinner (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Thu Aug 28 15:41:46 EDT 2003
sonu nigam had some songs in tamil!
there was one in jeans, varayo, but i'm sure there are more song!
- From: x (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Fri Aug 29 03:42:22 EDT 2003
All tamil MD's should avoid him.
- From: sk (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Fri Aug 29 12:52:01 EDT 2003
- From: IRRRRRRRRRR (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Fri Aug 29 13:15:24 EDT 2003
Udit sucks rocks. Just filling up ....
- From: MusicIsLife (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Fri Aug 29 15:47:42 EDT 2003
My opinion is Sonu Nigam could do better in Tamil compared to Udit (though both are my favs)
- From: seudoirfan (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Fri Aug 29 16:00:01 EDT 2003
pls contact IR to find out why hindi singers like asha bhosle and lata mangeshkar where made to sing in the 1980s....
and how about the person who sang "yamnai atrile" - wrote it the way she sang....
if there singing is bearable then why not udit's ?..
dont bash arr for the trend set by IR
- From: seudoirfan (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Fri Aug 29 16:00:38 EDT 2003
*were ( instead of where)
- From: Sampath (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Fri Aug 29 17:18:29 EDT 2003
Udit Narayan is a good singer - but in Hindi. True he has sung some good tunes in Tamil, but he kills the language. The credit for the hits should go to the music directors. Every song that Udit has sung should have been sung by UNNI MENON - great voice, good diction and it would have been more pleasant to the ears
- From: Neel D (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Fri Aug 29 23:17:25 EDT 2003
Vidyasagar is not a Tamilian. Why does he care if Udit murders Tamil or Sadhana murders Tamil. Should we even expect him to care when the Tamilian MDs themselves are becoming increasingly dependent on tamil-murdering singers for their success.
- From: kumar (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Tue Sep 2 02:44:28 EDT 2003
The only way to hit such a trend is by promoting MP3s of such albums.
Dont buy a single copy. The music would be popular and the producer will kick some butt off these MDs when he goes broke.
- From: x (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Tue Sep 2 03:11:00 EDT 2003
No takers in Hindi, hence singing in tamil.
- From: x (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Tue Sep 2 03:13:08 EDT 2003
Thrash like seudoirfan fans...
Every thing will be ok
- From: Ravi (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Tue Sep 2 06:32:49 EDT 2003
Singers are the mercy of MDs. They can make or break singers. Do u think good talent alone makes a person popular? We had many discussions even in this forum about many talented singers not getting appreciable chances.
I guess the MDs are to be blamed about choosing North Indian singers. Well they have to make sure the diction is right - the singers will not be able to do so. I guess the North Indian dialect is every different compared to the south Indian languages - thats why we see the strong accent and literal murder of the language.
Isnt it pathetic that earlier people were cynical about North Indian actresses making their fray into south Indian cinema when they could not even utter a word in Tamil but now, even worse, singers who cant even speak a word in Tamil are singing Tamil songs!!! What a way to go!!! :-(
100% MDs are to be blamed. The songs which have become hits because of the tune/music - MDs take a sentimental value for the singer too and tend to use their voice repeatedly. Though people enjoy the music, the opinion that the language has been murdered is unanimous.
- From: Chilaka (@ )
on: Fri Sep 26 09:16:34 EDT 2003
Why are we so sceptical to these matters? Don't South Indians sing in Hindi? The voice of SPB is so absurd in Hum Apke Hain Kaun but still the songs were superhit because of the music. Why are we quite about this? That's one reason he could not shine in Hindi for a long time.
Hasn't ARR promoted South Indians in Bollywood .... the influx has to be both ways.
Udit Narayan is an excellent singer and his voice has suited some of the numbers very well.... no one can deny the fact that his pronounciation has improved a lot. While I do not totally disagree to the fact his pronounciation needs to improve, let us stop being so cynical.
- From: alualu..aluuualuuuu (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Fri Sep 26 09:21:46 EDT 2003
WHY UDIT NARAYANAN SINGING TAMIL
First tell is that tamil? --
cha till date I thought it was greek..
- From: marshu (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Fri Sep 26 10:19:43 EDT 2003
When you partly understand and partly don't understand a song it increases the interest in the song - atleast thats what happens to me. Sometimes I laugh at the pronunciations, but its not unbearable.
- From: Sk (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Fri Sep 26 11:05:21 EDT 2003
Should be happy the fact that a guy who has not much clue about Tamil comes and sings in tamil. He's awesome in my opinion, Long live UDIT!
- From: Reddy (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Fri Sep 26 12:06:03 EDT 2003
Udit is top singer in Telugu now.He sings all those tunes in Tamil...that apart voice il irukkum kurumbu thanam veru yaaridamum illaiye....Now a days every tamil hero wants Udit to sing one song atleast for them...Boys telgu version la Udit Rendu song paadirukkan....Nice melodious youthful voice.....Allu allu...Thallu thllu....Deepavali tamil release la Niraiya pattu Udit paadiirukkan...kelugo...CMK.Reddy.
- From: Choochan (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Sat Sep 27 09:25:36 EDT 2003
Udhit is the only National singer. First time in the Histroy of Cinema, a north Indian singer is singing in most of the South Indian films. Recently he started singing in Malayalam also. Udit is singing more in Telugu than Tamil. He is now singing in Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam and Kannada. It is a short wave. it will go off shortly.
- From: MusicIsLife (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Sat Sep 27 14:02:27 EDT 2003
Malayam Film world found disgrace after Shakeela.
- From: MADDY (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Sat Sep 27 21:29:45 EDT 2003
i truly blame ARR for using southie singers in Bollywood...... his choice of M.G.Shreekumar for "kissa hum likhenge" in "Doli saja ke rakhna" fetches him 0 out of 10 marks from me......he spolied that song......
maybe the same way u pundits feel abt. hindi singers in Tamil songs....i accept this theory...
- From: Sooraj Sadanandan (@ )
on: Thu Nov 6 01:25:05 EST 2003
Udit is a talented singer but he needs to improve his pronounciation when he sings Tamil or Telgu or Kannada.I dont think he has any chance in Malayalam films.He just sung one song in "CID moosa" which starts with "Hindi lyrics"
- From: Jac (@ )
on: Sun Dec 12 07:42:27 EST 2004
Give him a break.He is one of the talented singers I know.How can u not praise his ability to sing in so many languages?He can sing a song with so much feeling.He will always be my fav.
- From: AV (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Sun Dec 12 09:24:12 EST 2004
Its not Udit Narayanan, but Udit Narayan.
- From: angry (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Sun Dec 12 10:56:31 EST 2004
Why all these complains??
Many songs sung by udit narayan has become hits like kadhalikkum pennin, soniya soniya, kadhal pisase, allu allu etc.
If u dont like then dont listen. U have choices people.
- From: j (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Sun Dec 12 11:15:56 EST 2004
excuse me... i noted someone here saying sadhana sargam was killing tamil. let me tell u that her voice and pronounciation never fail 2 do justice to the lyrics. in fact she sings in tamil better than some of the 'tamil' female singers we have.
- From: sankar (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Sun Dec 12 11:36:28 EST 2004
Kathal pisase, he says paruvayillai instead of paravayillai.
- From: Guess Me (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Sun Dec 12 11:50:27 EST 2004
Certainly not Sadhana Sargam. She sang "Snehithane" from Alaipayuthey too well that I couldnt believe at first she was not tamil. Infact the later hits like Konjum Mainakkale(Kandukondain), Anbe(Rhythm), Amma(New) are very good.
- From: Ravi (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Wed Dec 15 15:40:14 EST 2004
Sadhna Sargam is alright, though I didn't care for some of her pronunciation in Konjum Mainakkale. Otherwise she is not too bad. But Udit! Man, he is in a class by himself in Tamil. He's good in Hindi (ARR-Udit combo is great), but I can't stand it when ARR and Vidyasagar, otherwise talented MDs, use him.
- From: red (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Wed Dec 15 16:47:40 EST 2004
thats gr8 , for the first time i heard this!
Udith is very very bad!!
i admit that he songs goodly IN HINDI But in tamil, it's a wash-out
it's incredible that he hav more demanded than gr8 young talented singer.
Long Live to SPB & Tippu!!!
by the way join tippu yahoo fans group :
- From: Jeevan Gomez (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Tue Dec 21 05:23:47 EST 2004
I could not read this entire thread.
Iam glad that I found a forum where I can express my two cents,in regard to this topic.
Firstly the trend of having a singer, who does not know Tamil ( or for any other language he is singing in ) does a lot of damage to the song.
The intonation to the song is completely lost, the beautiful lyrics written by the lyricist, loses its intended beauty, the local talent loses its opportunity, and end of the day I as an end user hate to listen to such *Half Baked* songs, which fail to deliver value and is grossly Irritating. (For which I have paid my hard earned money already)!!
There are numerous Tamil songs that have great melody and orchestration, which ultimately lack lustre, due to the voice Track (which in my view is the beautifying track of all Tracks) being bleak.
I urge all Music Directors, and Lyricists and all concerened to excercise due dilligence in reversing the trend. Many of the serious music lovers are now reverting to songs of yester years to avoid listening to songs that lack diction. PLEASE STOP THE DAMAGE BEING DONE TO THE LANGUAGE, THE MUSIC, AND THE PUBLIC!!.
- From: dinesh (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Tue Dec 21 06:23:29 EST 2004
hey sadhana is great guys!!yes,udit really suck*s!!but,i feel in lady singers Madhushree is really bad,eventhough she sounds alike like Sadhana,but her tamil shows her weekness,Sadhana has great voice & her tamil is good!!
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum