Topic started by Neelakantan Iyer (@ ppp3-27.bom.vsnl.net.in) on Thu May 7 15:59:40 EDT 1998.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
I came to this forum by accident and boy was I hooked...
Have you noticed the 2nd interlude from "Poongatru Pudidanadu" from Moonram Pirai (where the sound of train is superimposed... with the instrumental piece) being REUSED in "En Vaazhvile Varum Anbe Vaa" (Film: Tambikku Enda Ooru)?
I think it matches perfectly. And the reason behind this perhaps because of the following:
The first song "Poongatru" was replacesd in its Hindi version SADMA as "Ae Zindagi Gale Laga Le" which in turn took the Tamil avatar as "En Vaazhvile" in Tambikku Enda Ooru".
Any other similar incident you know of?
- From: mfm (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Thu May 7 21:53:17 EDT 1998
Neels, I agree with you I had this feeling for a long time and I really confirmed it last week by playing those songs back-to-back. Inspite of repetition that is a marvellous mixing by Raaja.
Another incident is 'Adi Aathadi... song's interlude gets used in the 'Va Va anbe Poojai undu...' song. I am referring to the continuous flute piece. Also in the same film, the prelude of Kalakalakkum Maniyosai resembles with another songs prelude which I am not able to remember now. There are couple of other incidents that strikes but I can't remember one of the songs in the pair. I will put them once I know the exact songs.
- From: Karthik S (@ )
on: Thu Apr 12 03:51:25 EDT 2001
Just wondering! What was the reason that IR did not retain a hindi version of 'poongatru pudhithaanadhu' in Sadma? It was an incredible composition much ahead of its times. I felt it would have sounded equally good in hindi, given good lyrics.
But the other song 'aye zindagi', did that come first or did the thambikku entha ooru song come first? I thot IR composed the tamil version first and maybe used it in hindi Sadma at Balumahendra's behest? But as I said earlier, why change this song in the first place?
Actually some IR songs when used in hindi have a magical effect, song in question 'kaatre' from Johny, used as 'naina' in Aur ek prem kahani! Man what a song, even in hindi! Its a pity it was not promoted well, plus music really wasted this album!
- From: Karthik S (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Thu Apr 12 03:56:33 EDT 2001
Now with regard to the topic thread....I've read somewhere that taking off your interlude/ BG piece to create a new song was a very common habit of Shankar Jaikishen. I can remember ARR's background music in Roja, when Madhu meets Nazar for the first time in the army camp...that bg music was used as 'raakozhi rendum' in Uzhavan!
Again, the whole song in Pavitra 'azhagu nilave' was in the bg in Pudhiya Mugham, towards the end.
- From: eden (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Thu Apr 12 05:10:58 EDT 2001
The clarinet prelude of `mAnguyilE, poonguyilE' is the tune for `thooLiyilE ada vandha'.
& I'm sure IR has repeated the first interlude of `nAnAga nAnillai thAyE' in another song...is it `poongAtru thirumbumA'?
- From: Kumar (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Thu Apr 12 07:35:55 EDT 2001
Same as a bg score in 'Poovella kaetuppar' being
resued as a song tune in 'Dheena'...
gosh.. cant remember which song it was.. :((
watched PK last week and noticed the similarity
- From: Karthik S (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Thu Apr 12 08:44:38 EDT 2001
Ungalathu mudhal TFM DF posting'a evlo chamatha thoosi thatti irukken paarungal!
- From: Common Friend (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Thu Apr 12 10:25:36 EDT 2001
The rum bum bum number in MMKR has its origin in tfm in Meendum kokila. The scene is where kamal fumbles in the court while arguing. Actually, the same kind of tune I heard it in an hindi film called Maa and kushbu was a child artist in that film. I have mentioned this before also.
ARR has done the usage of BGM to song not once but several times. Roja is a good example. Some BGMs in may madam have also come as songs. I don't remember it right now.
- From: Swamiji (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Thu Apr 12 14:17:22 EDT 2001
Usilam patti & chandralekha
- From: nivas (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Thu Apr 12 16:15:57 EDT 2001
"123456..endha ooru enna paeru" and "kaeladi en paavaiyae" songs have more similarities. did anybody hear that?
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum