Topic started by JPS (@ ppp45-216.lvsb.vsnl.net.in) on Thu Jul 2 09:24:42 EDT 1998.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
- Old responses
- From: peesoo (@ horus.erlm.siemens.de)
on: Thu Jul 9 08:57:40 EDT 1998
Thanks for ur support Mr. Mohan. ;-)
and Mr. Anban really strikes back! ;-) Good one.. keep it up. Coming to Mr. Satish's classical note:
Music will form the soul of the film and eight maestros will
compose it. There is ghazal virtuoso Hariharan, Vanraj Bhatia,
Pandit Raghunath Seth, Telugu superstar Keeravani, Raveendran,
Bhupen Hazarika, Ilayaraja and A.R. Rehman.
Ilayaraja has agreed in principle to compose the music for
the poems that will lace the film. Negotiations are on with
Rehman to tie up the logistics.
It sounds that IR will be scoring for some poems. Thats all and it did not mention that he will be working together with ARR. IR will be scoring some portion and ARR will be scoring some other portions independently.
Long back there was a movie, kaNNil theriyum kathaigal in which each song was scored by different MDs, though never worked together. [I guess, IR scored 'naanoru ponnOviyam kaNdaen adhilE' and shankar ganesh scored 'naan unna nenachchaen'] I feel tht the above article sounds something similar.
- From: srinivasan (@ www-relay4.pa-x.dec.com)
on: Thu Jul 9 10:11:37 EDT 1998
I don't belive this.
You making fool out of us
- From: Prakash Balakrishnan (@ gate5.ca.us.ibm.com)
on: Thu Jul 9 12:34:42 EDT 1998
'KaNNil theriyum kadhaigaL' padaththukku MSV, GKV,IR, S-G, VK ???? scored the music.
Same way for the Malayalam film I hope.
Still I can tell that "Nothing Is Imposible" in this world. One day IR - ARR together will score the music for a film. You will all going to see that.
I can't agree that ARR only scoring Morden songs.. He also scored some good songs like "NarumugaiyE, NarumugaiyE..." from Iruvar,
"poovukkuL oLithurkkum adhisayamE...." from Jeans
"KaNNukku Mai azhagu...." from pudhiya mugam
"Margazhi poovE..." from May Madham
"Mettu Podu..." & "En kadhalE..." from Duet
are melodies.. and there were no Rock, Disco or Mordern pop, etc. He can also score such kind of song..
Where as Raja is also not a village MD. He scored fine morden songs..
"Raja, Rajathi raja..." from Agni Natchathiram
"Madai thirandhu..."From N-izhalGaL
"Kalakalamaga kadhalukku N-angaL arpaNam.." from Punnagai Mannan
"poovE sen poovE un vaasal varum..." (Classical western in this song) from Sollath thudikkudhu Manasu..
"en iniya pon N-ilavE..." from Moodu Pani
"...Vanengilum Deepavali..." from Mundram Pirai.
"illamai idho, idho...." from Sagalakala vallavan.
kANdippaga IR-ARR iruvarum serththu oru iniya isaiyai kodukka mudiyum. iruvarukku sondha prachanaigaL irukkalam. adhaiyum idhaiyum Samandha paduttha kudaadhu. If that problem solved then they can work together isn't it??
- From: mohan (@ gw1.cat.com)
on: Thu Jul 9 15:11:24 EDT 1998
Ahaaa...!! Enna oru arumaya karpanai... ungaloda kanavu appadiye oru movie aakka try pandringala??
good luck...! :-)>
- From: Moorthi (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Thu Jul 9 20:48:45 EDT 1998
very glad to think about this. If its going to happen TFM will reach another mile stone.
See there are possiblities for this rumer to be true.
1. Kamal- who thinks different and worked with both music directros, and also he is a mad to make his film perfect. As kamal really trying to get a good music director for "Marudha Nayagam" ,
He may try to blend these to top guys (Top in India).
2. "Marudhanayagam"'s Music director is unknown. And it is in suspense, before 2 months, I don't know the present details.
3. ARR did a very great job with IR in Punnagai Mannan, that bit of music, u can understand their mental co-ordination like IR and Hariprasad Chwrasiya in "Nothing But Wind", ARR and Kadhri Gopalnath" in Duet, ARR and Hariduvar mangalam in Jeans, and lot more.
4. They can achieve. If they love music, they can achieve, If they feel Music is their own creation, that is the loss for us.
5. As IR always says that he get tunes from air, and ARR always says "Ellam Iraivan Seyal" , Let us hope, we will get an Oscar award for "Marudhanagam" , music done by IR and ARR.
Do u want perfection or time pass. O sorry, u may like any thing , Buy a true "Kalaignnan" never can give up his work just for others words or anything else in the world. You know Sivaji, he never give up anything for others sayings.
If the film is once made , thats it. U never can repair it. U know story about "Jurasic Park","Titanic", "VeeraPandiya KattaPomman"
Ofcourse adding to the Perfection, Kamal may expect to prove himself in the world level. Please guys let us encourage this "Kalaignanan" who is bleeding for "Kalai". My hearty greetings to Kamal - "Kalai".
- From: Anban (@ pm3-fdl01-ppp-131.tcccom.net)
on: Thu Jul 9 22:20:15 EDT 1998
Anban's Thanks to Mr. Mohan.
I just wanted to entertain TFM fans so i wrote
those lines. Mr. Prakash, i never said anything
like IR can only score village music and ARR can
score only western types.
Yarukku ethu nalla varumo athe pannathanga
nalla irukkum. But if u really want to argue
about IR, i am ready. I can assure Mr. Prakash
that ARR CAN NEVER score music for a song which
will exactly fit with situations which are in
Village movies. He may start well but end up
with hitech stuff. Please take just this bit
as an example, 'Inji iduppalaki' and 'potri
paadadi penne' from Devar Magan.
You can also argue that IR can never score
western as ARR is doing now. I agree. Generation
change, Annakkili made a turn to TFM, also ROJA
made a turn to TFM.
Kilakku cheemaiyile is a village movie music
by ARR. Eththanai TFM fans athilirukka songs
ellam gnabakam vaichirukkangannu oru survey
edunga. Agni natchathirm and Anjali koncham
rich people oriented stuff, music by IR, athile
songs ellam think panni parunga.
Rendu perum sernthu Music podum alavukku oru
classic story kidaikkanum, good director should
be ready to direct the film. A producer like
KTK, AVM or Rajkamal has to produce it. I used to
think always onething friends,
10$ CD vankittu 2 songsthan nallarukkunnu
solra namakke ivlo argue panna thonrathe, antha
mathiri oru movie panna producers and directors
evlo yosippanga. Anyway my best wishes for both
good guys to win in case if they join hands.
I am leaving out of this topic as i feel
everybody is very serious and i don't like
- From: Raghav (@ ppp12-67.bng.vsnl.net.in)
on: Fri Jul 10 01:13:04 EDT 1998
Hey! Anban, what's going on here? We all are friends. We are discussing one topic. That's all. Don't take anything seriously. If anybody wants to take it seriously, let them have it. Why do you bother about that. Be cool and let's have fun from your side. Will you?
- From: S.P MAHENDRAN (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Mon Jul 13 01:28:04 EDT 1998
What all of you think if ILLAIYARAJA and KARTHIK RAJA work together to score music for MARUDHANAYAGAM?I think this one would be nice.Both of them can score different kind of music.This one can make history in tamil film music.
- From: ;) (@ nc36.pr.mcs.net)
on: Wed Jul 15 20:34:35 EDT 1998
Can someone please confirm if rahman, raja, kamalahaasan, zakir hussain, karthik raja, andrew weber are all together joining hands to compose music as one team for marudanayagan?
- From: :) (@ webgate0.mot.com)
on: Thu Jul 16 05:32:39 EDT 1998
Nithin, (@ nc36.pr.mcs.net)
Do you think the film is going to ever get made at all ?
- From: sree (@ moth.cs.concordia.ca)
on: Fri Jul 17 12:17:55 EDT 1998
MD for next shankar movie is ARR.This was told by suresh chakravarthy in the indiadirect.com top 10 songs countdown.
- From: S.P MAHENDRAN (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Tue Jul 21 00:00:39 EDT 1998
IR and Kamal has give a chance to KR to score music for Marudhanayagam.KR only have one tamil movie now on his hand after Kadhala Kadhala.IR believe that KR can score music for this movie.First,Kamal want IR to score music but IR refuse because he have many tamil,telungu,malayalam,kanadam and one hindi movies.So IR give a chance to KR.Kamal also agree to this because Kamal very impresed with KR music in KK.I think IR also help his son to score music for this film.
THANK YOU,VERY MUCH.
- From: Kalanjiyam (@ proxy.qatar.net.qa)
on: Wed Jul 22 13:05:12 EDT 1998
KR is busy in HFM. So he has given the job to Yuvan SankaraRaaja who has vowed to push ARR IR and KR out of TFM by his mesmerising music. Kamal was very much impressed by his 'Dappanguthu' (sahikkalai) music in Kalyana galaaattaaa. and Velai.
- From: p.s.gopi (@ 203-5-163.ipt.aol.com)
on: Sat Jul 25 02:59:36 EDT 1998
Mahendra sami....yennachu??? vayil konjam
- From: k.r.ravi (@ 131.houston-06.tx.dial-access.att.net)
on: Sat Jul 25 03:47:28 EDT 1998
The concept above seems like too many cooks will spoil the food.By the way when it comes to film music.too many minds working for a same film with different creative attitudes may not be a good i dea. I prefer ILAYARAAJA alone to score the music.for he is unbeatbale and a genius in giving the Bacground score which no one can refute.being a historical movie..i think the mood of the film is more important than the songs, hence IR could be the best bet. Anyway lets see.
- From: thirupathy (@ ppp36-97.bng.vsnl.net.in)
on: Fri Jul 31 09:47:29 EDT 1998
Ungala nambi naan eatho ennamonnu idhai padicha ivaalavu time waste pannitingale ...
- From: Ravi (@ envy.cs.umass.edu)
on: Fri Jul 31 11:00:06 EDT 1998
tirupathy: You are right. We have an obligation to new comers. So I am retiring this thread.
- From: surendran (@ 166-32-201.ipt.aol.com)
on: Sun Oct 11 05:00:18 EDT 1998
I too don't belive this.
You making fool out of us
- From: devarajan (@ )
on: Sun Jan 14 08:22:29 EST 2001
send some pics of mastero !
- From: devarajan (@ )
on: Sun Jan 14 08:22:40 EST 2001
send some pics of mastero ir... !
- From: vardhini (@ )
on: Sat Jun 30 06:51:23 EDT 2001
I love the latest IR songs in movie friends. esp the songs Manjal poosum maalai neram and
chaiya chaiya oh chaiyya. What's your opinion?
IR's songs sung by women are 2 good. I feel he creates music with the mind of a woman
- From: Prakaash,M. (@ )
on: Sat Oct 25 14:00:03 EDT 2003
Good Joke of Yeear 2003
It is Impossible
- From: * (@ )
on: Tue Jun 1 07:08:42 EDT 2004
Finally found a movie where IR and ARR's name figure together in the Music Credits:
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum