Topic started by Ravana (@ 188.8.131.52) on Thu Dec 20 15:40:13 EST 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
I feel that she is the most awful singer that I have had the misfortune to hear.Her singing is awful and is lifeless.Why does her family keep giving her ample opportunity to bring down their efforts?The biggest culprit here has to be IR who continually subjects his audience to the endless screeching and off-key renditions by his daughter.KR is the second who tries hard to promote his sister but is fighting a losing battle!Just when I feel YSR has understood the effect of Bhavatharini's voice on his tracks,by not putting her on,he ruins that though by giving her a song.
She has sung many awful songs,but her most awful songs to date are
Sadugudu from MTV
Thendral Varum from Friends
Poothathu from PKP
Muththamida Vendum from Vanginathan
Nee Illai Endral from Dheena
Most of her songs are badly sung,so don't you think it's about time that she retires from TFM and allows us,the unsuspecting audience members,a chance to enjoy some good music?
- From: arun_uk (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Thu Dec 20 17:49:24 EST 2001
This is your personal opinion. Most people would agree that she doesn't have the best voice in the world, but she is 'musically' well educated & gives her best. All the more her tamil pronounciation is good, unlike many others.
Are you so sure Mr.Ravana that there aren't people out there who appreciate or like her voice? I know a few people who like her voice. Everyone's an individual Mr.Ravana, with their own perceptions and ideas. Moreover what is wrong with a family member employing another in his own bloody business? If you don't like it stay away & that's good for you!
- From: tigger (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Thu Dec 20 17:57:35 EST 2001
She might not be as good as other contemporary singers but she is definitely not as bad as you make her out to be. She has had some good songs too:
alai meethu vilaiyadum, from kathal kavithai
mayil pola, from Barathi
Are there other singers out there better than her who have not had a chance to make it into film music? highly probable. They (IR, KR, Yuvan) etc. give her a chance because she is family after all and maybe they think that with the right encouragement she might improve. I applaud them for that.
It is ok to critisize a performer but please do not humiliate her the way you have done just because you have access to a computer and know to type.
- From: mucic (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Thu Dec 20 18:11:34 EST 2001
she is pronouncing good ..she is for better than any other hindi singers.they simply kill the tamil.
why the family matter comes here.
can u mention anyone who is not using their relative
everyone is using (if they have chance)so it is not the matter of family..
she is not as bad as you mention ravana....
she is getting what she deserved...
other music directors are not using her because she is ilayaraaja's daughter...that f... ego there..that's all
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum