is arr going down ir coming back?
Topic started by thinktank (@ 126.96.36.199) on Wed Jun 17 07:16:05 EDT 1998.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.
is ir back after hi kathaliku mariyathai? and do critics feel arr is going out for some reasons? what are the reasons
- From: Srikanth (@ 68.minneapolis-07.mn.dial-access.att.net)
on: Wed Jun 17 08:05:31 EDT 1998
ARr is going out! where - to shopping.
Good joke, it is a illusion that ARr is going out.
Raja's tasks , rather than ARr he as compete with Deva, Sirpi, Adithyan, AnandShalin,vidhya sagar, m.mani,bala bharathy etc...
There are many mds now in TFM....All of them are now popular.
(The Bullet proof against Raja fans : I am not talking about Raja's skill here - it is only his popularity)
- From: Srinath (@ socks12d.raleigh.ibm.com)
on: Wed Jun 17 08:22:50 EDT 1998
For once I agree with Srikanth ! Though ARR might not last as long as IR did, he is still a force to contend with and, on any given day, is better than Deva, Sirpi and others put together. But he could find himself in a tough situation, giving pedestrian music, if he doesn't tighten up his act. Perhaps the success of people like Deva and Sirpi are giving ARR the jitters. I would advise him to play it cool and not compete with them on their terms. I really don't think IR is coming back - if he did go anywhere in the first place. His image is so strongly moulded that it is too late to be changed now. IMO, he will continue giving us gems every now and then. Apart from that he would be better off with non-filmi music. We must also understand that Balu Mahendra, KB, Bharathiraja and Fazil are also at the twilight of their careers. It is the end of an Era and the beginning of a new one. Even if IR wishes to continue, he is going to find fewer channels of expression than before. The end of his productivity is not going to take away his achievements and that is what we should look forward to.
I would repeat your quote to ARR fans lest I am misunderstood - "I am not talking about Raja's skill here - it is only his popularity" - that is on the downswing.
- From: Srikanth (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Wed Jun 17 09:42:21 EDT 1998
Srinath : I am a Tamil music fan ,
I take the best from everyone,
it is not ARR or Raja,
(a free grenade for IR fans : I know a western song copied by (or which inspired ) arr in Indian - Kapel yei poyachu ....I will play in my next neyar neram program..
- From: six2one (@ bones.deneb.com)
on: Wed Jun 17 09:53:11 EDT 1998
After hitting a singles (KM) when IR is trying to
COMING BACK....ARR hit a loooong six (Jenas) and
the ball went UP UP UP UP UP...and IS GOING DOWN.
- From: Srinath (@ socks15d.raleigh.ibm.com)
on: Wed Jun 17 09:54:17 EDT 1998
How about starting a thread where fans of one particular MD come out with what they like in another MD ? For example, I could specify what I like in ARR's music that IR's music lacks, while you and Udhaya can identify what you like in IR's music as compared to ARR. And as a show of friendship, I shall refuse the free grenade offered by you :-)))
BTW, Bullet-proof, grenade ??? Are we starting a war here ? Well, whose got the nuclear weapons ? :-))))
- From: Karthigeyan A Premakumari (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Wed Jun 17 14:23:57 EDT 1998
I was wondering what this talk is all about! You know Ilayaraja has had his hay days and has been in his peak (or many peaks?). Now it's time for ARR to relish his 'peak-dom'. So why not just leave him free to enjoy it? He's been giving quite refreshing stuff with his every new venture. I think that should take care of it all.
ps: It's good that Ilayaraja has scored well in 'KM' but that's not to say he's coming back.
- From: reasoning (@ 220.127.116.11)
on: Wed Jun 17 14:49:25 EDT 1998
i personally think that arr is a force. so is ir. but ir days are almost over, and giving his last few miraculous effort while arr is still beginning! both are a big credit to tfm, i am proud to be born in a place like tm!!! with great musical talents. one recognized as a musical mestro and the other a genius
- From: Krishna (@ mailserver01.sb.com)
on: Wed Jun 17 18:44:41 EDT 1998
Its just gratifying to know that the people who like ARR's music are the juniors and reasonings of the world. It feels great to be on the otherside supporting IR with the likes of Srinath and others.
- From: nayakan (@ )
on: Wed Feb 11 16:48:00 EST 2004
Avanai Nirutha Sollu .... Naan Niruthuran
- From: nayakan* (@ 18.104.22.168)
on: Wed Feb 11 18:24:00 EST 2004
Ada Pavinkala....Sariyana Potti
- From: x (@ 22.214.171.124)
on: Thu Feb 12 03:10:19 EST 2004
IR was always coming up only never went down.
Well ARR could never come up and was and went down only.
- From: x (@ 126.96.36.199)
on: Thu Feb 12 03:22:05 EST 2004
I am keeping watch on some threads.
When these are removed I will conclude with confidence that TFM page Admins and members are also part of IR basher. And they are the major part of the people who has created an unhealthy environment in TFM.
- From: paran (@ 188.8.131.52)
on: Thu Feb 12 04:55:50 EST 2004
"IR was always coming up only never went down.
Well ARR could never come up and was and went down only. "
yes he was went when was he went, up and down was when he went to was up and went down. When?..
- From: C~P (@ 184.108.40.206)
on: Thu Feb 12 13:10:07 EST 2004
It doesn't matter even if you keep a wall clock as long as you make blind statements!
Just as Paran said, I dont understand what you are trying to say. Please be more clear.
List all pages of this thread
Back to the Forum